The St Francis Justice and Mercy Ministry asks:
Why is it an act of mercy to oppose the death penalty?
The right to a fair trial is one of the foundations of our justice system, yet it often proves meaningless to the poor and vulnerable in our midst. Nearly
all inmates currently on death row in the United States were unable to
afford their own attorneys at the times of their trials. Instead, they were
assigned court-appointed attorneys, who often lack the experience
necessary for capital cases and are overworked and underpaid. This
combination of factors often results in poorly-handled cases where
mitigating factors (e.g. intellectual disability or severe mental illness) and
tools like DNA evidence are never mentioned at trial, and often, not
permitted in evidence after trial!
It is not uncommon for individuals with intellectual disability or severe
mental illness to go undiagnosed and untreated, particularly if those
individuals are living in poverty. Such conditions elevate the likelihood of
these individuals receiving death sentences in capital cases, as well as
compounding their risk of wrongful conviction. They are also more likely to
become victims of violent crime themselves.
In 2017 alone, at least 20 of the 23 people executed (87%) showed
evidence of severe mental illness, intellectual disability, brain damage, or
severe trauma. The death penalty denies our responsibility to care for this
often poor and vulnerable population.
Do you agree? Do you dis-agree? We would be glad to discuss this issue
with you. Come to one of our meetings, first and third Fridays of each
month, 10:00 in the Meeting House, or email me at agbassage@gmail.com
Thanks for reading this.
Annie Grace.