I've been involved in making liturgical music for most of my life, and it has been one of the important ways that I've stayed close to the Church. Along the way I have worked with many mentors and colleagues in that regard, one of whom is David Haas. If you follow the world of music, then you are probably familiar with David by name. If you don't, then think of song tunes like "You Are Mine" or "We Are Called" or "Blest Are They," which are beloved by many among Christian worshippers. Any Catholic hymn book is filled with dozens of David's creations, and some Protestant ones are, too.
You may be aware that David, who lives here in the Twin Cities, has been in the news recently because of allegations of misconduct against adult women over the course of many years. He has not been charged with any criminal offenses, but it appears that at least some of the claims are credible and he has issued a public apology for his behavior. While I was never aware of any of this prior to it being revealed in the press recently, I've known David for 35 years, and he was an active and generous parishioner in a parish which I previously served as pastor. It is disorienting to know how to think about all of this.
And it has posed a difficult question for Church leaders and musicians about whether to perform David's music at liturgical gatherings. Some dioceses in the United States have prohibited it outright. Others have not put any restrictions in place. For those that have, the concern is not to punish David but rather to avoid further traumatizing parishioners who are victims of abuse, whether by David or anybody else. Our own archdiocese has discontinued using his songs during liturgies involving the whole local church at the Cathedral, but it has been left up to the individual parishes to make our own best judgments about that question. There has been a variety of discernment about that among the parishes.
I and our parish liturgical/musical leadership met several weeks ago and decided to put a pause on the use of David's music here at Pax Christi. While that means the loss of many cherished songs, we are persuaded by the necessary pastoral concern for possible victims. Ours is not a flat-out and forever "policy," but it is at least a temporary decision that may be reviewed again later. And we may have room for exceptions for more specific gatherings like weddings or funerals when such music is specifically requested by a family.
Nobody benefits from such a sad situation, and everybody suffers—the victims, the parishes, the pastoral musicians, and yes, David. Let's pray for compassion for all who are being adversely affected by these events.
CLICK ON IMAGE BELOW FOR A VIDEO MESSAGE FROM FR. MIKE